Some of the most moving stories of the War Between the States are not about victories at all. One of them comes from the failed Confederate assault on Fort Sanders at Knoxville, Tennessee, in November 1863. Trapped in a ditch at the foot of the fort, Southern soldiers were suffering terribly. One young man volunteered to run back across open ground for water, and when he returned with his load, the Union defenders did something no one expected. General John B. Gordon later recorded the story in his memoir, and it remains one of the finest examples of courage and respect between American soldiers.

Longstreet Goes to East Tennessee
After the great Confederate victory at Chickamauga in September 1863, the Union Army of the Cumberland was bottled up in Chattanooga. General Braxton Bragg sent Lieutenant General James Longstreet and his corps, veterans of the Army of Northern Virginia, northeast toward Knoxville. Their goal was to drive out Union Major General Ambrose E. Burnside, whose army had occupied the city in September.
East Tennessee was a divided region, with strong Union loyalties in many counties. Holding Knoxville and its railroad was important to both sides. By mid-November, Burnside had pulled back inside a ring of earthworks around the city, and Longstreet laid siege.
The Fort on the Hill
The strongest point in the Union line was an earthen bastion on the northwest side of town. Confederates had begun it earlier in the war as Fort Loudon. The Federals renamed it Fort Sanders after Brigadier General William P. Sanders, who was mortally wounded in a skirmish outside Knoxville on November 18, 1863.
The fort was protected by a wide, deep ditch with steep sides. Reports describe it as about twelve feet wide and several feet deep, much deeper than Longstreet believed. Through his field glasses, he had watched a Union soldier seem to walk across the ditch, not realizing the man had crossed on a plank. Union defenders also strung telegraph wire between stumps in front of the fort to trip attackers. On the freezing night before the attack, according to many accounts, they poured water over the outer slope so it would freeze into a slick sheet of ice.
The Assault of November 29, 1863
Longstreet ordered a surprise attack at dawn on November 29, with brigades from Major General Lafayette McLaws’s division leading the way. The men were brave and determined, but the plan went badly wrong. The attackers tripped on the wires, then reached the ditch and found it far too deep to cross easily. They had no scaling ladders. Men climbed on each other’s shoulders and tried to scramble up the icy wall while Union troops fired down into them and rolled lit artillery shells over the parapet like hand grenades.
Several Confederate flags were planted on the parapet for a moment, and their bearers were shot down. Within about twenty minutes the attack was over. Confederate losses were reported as 813 men killed, wounded or missing, while the Union defenders lost only a few dozen. Many of the Southern casualties fell in or near that ditch.

The Dash for Water
In the ditch at the base of the fort, the Confederates who had not been killed were stuck. They were partly sheltered from Union fire, but they could not climb into the fort or get back across the open field without being shot. Wounded and exhausted men were desperate for water.
A young Confederate soldier offered to risk his life for them. He gathered canteens and ran back across the open ground to fill them. Somehow he made it through unharmed. The harder part was the return trip, carrying the heavy, full canteens toward the waiting Union rifles. Gordon described the moment this way:
“He was fully alive to the fact that the chances were all against him; but, determined to relieve his suffering comrades or die in the effort, he started on his perilous run for the ditch at the fort.”
The Union soldiers on the parapet had him at their mercy. Instead of shooting, they held their fire and watched him come. Then, in Gordon’s words, they fired “a tremendous volley–not of deadly bullets from their guns, but of enthusiastic shouts from their throats.” The Federal soldiers cheered the young Rebel all the way to his comrades.
Gordon closed the story with a line that has been quoted ever since:
“If the annals of war record any incident between hostile armies which embodies a more beautiful and touching tribute by the brave to the brave, I have never seen it.”
How General Gordon Learned the Story
General Gordon was not at Knoxville himself. He was serving with the Army of Northern Virginia at the time. In his Reminiscences of the Civil War, published in 1903, he explained that he heard the story years later, during a visit to Knoxville, from a group of veterans from both armies who walked the old fort with him and agreed on the details. Gordon’s version notes the soldiers suffering under the sun, though the assault began on a cold dawn, so some details may have shifted with time. The heart of the story, a Confederate hero cheered by his enemies, is what both sides remembered.
Gordon included it in a chapter he titled “War by the Brave Against the Brave,” alongside other accounts of kindness between the lines, such as pickets trading tobacco for coffee across the Rappahannock. His point was that the soldiers of both armies were Americans who respected courage wherever they saw it.
John B. Gordon: A Soldier Who Knew Courage
Gordon knew a great deal about bravery under fire. A Georgian, he entered the war as captain of the “Raccoon Roughs” in the 6th Alabama Infantry. At Antietam on September 17, 1862, he held the Sunken Road, now called Bloody Lane, and was hit by five bullets. He might have drowned in the blood from a face wound if a bullet hole in his cap had not let it drain away. He survived, rose to command a corps and led the last charge of Lee’s army at Appomattox. After the war he served as a U.S. senator and governor of Georgia and was the first commander-in-chief of the United Confederate Veterans.
Read more about General Gordon on our site in Burning of the Wrightsville Bridge, 1863: Gordon’s Georgians and a Can of Gunpowder, and learn about another kind of courage in Civil War Color Bearers: How Sgt. Clancy Saved the 1st Louisiana’s Flag at Gettysburg.
What Happened After Fort Sanders
The defeat at Fort Sanders came just four days after Bragg’s army was driven from Missionary Ridge at Chattanooga on November 25. With Union reinforcements under Sherman marching to relieve Burnside, Longstreet lifted the siege in early December and moved northeast, spending a hard winter in upper East Tennessee before rejoining Lee in Virginia in the spring of 1864.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the Battle of Fort Sanders?
It was a Confederate assault on a Union earthwork at Knoxville, Tennessee, on November 29, 1863. Longstreet’s attack failed in about twenty minutes, and it was the key fight of the Knoxville Campaign.
Who won the Battle of Fort Sanders?
The Union defenders under General Ambrose Burnside won. The Confederates suffered 813 casualties, while Union losses were very light.
Why did the attack on Fort Sanders fail?
The ditch was much deeper than Longstreet expected, the attackers had no ladders, and wire entanglements and icy slopes slowed them under heavy fire. Defenders also threw lit artillery shells down into the ditch.
Who was Fort Sanders named after?
It was named for Union Brigadier General William P. Sanders, who was mortally wounded near Knoxville on November 18, 1863. The Confederates had originally called it Fort Loudon.
Who told the story of the soldier who ran for water at Fort Sanders?
General John B. Gordon recorded it in his 1903 memoir Reminiscences of the Civil War. He heard it from veterans of both armies during a later visit to Knoxville.
Is Fort Sanders still standing today?
No. The site is now covered by a Knoxville neighborhood near the University of Tennessee, though historical markers note where the fort and the assault took place.
Honor Longstreet’s Veterans
Remember the courage shown at Knoxville with a General Robert E. Lee Headquarters Flag, carried in spirit by Longstreet’s corps of the Army of Northern Virginia, or the 3rd National Confederate Flag. Browse all of our Confederate Battle Flags and Rebel Flags.
Thanks for reading. Please share our posts with your friends and family so they too can learn more about Southern Heritage and History.
Brought to you by: Ultimate Flags

BUY Rebel Flags For Sale