“The Women Are the Devils”: The Defiant Ladies of Civil War Winchester, Virginia

In the spring of 1862, Abraham Lincoln’s Secretary of State came to Winchester, Virginia, hoping to find Union sentiment in the old Shenandoah Valley town. He left with a very different impression. Asked about the loyalty of the population, William H. Seward reportedly answered that “the men are all in the army, and the women are the devils.” The remark stuck, and it says as much about the courage of Winchester’s Southern women as any battle report.

Southern women of Winchester, Virginia, during the Civil War

Winchester: The Most Contested Town in the Confederacy

Winchester sits at the northern, or “lower,” end of the Shenandoah Valley, roughly 70 miles northwest of Washington, D.C. Roads and a railroad link ran through it, and the Valley itself was a natural highway pointed at Maryland and Pennsylvania. A Confederate army there could threaten the Federal capital. A Union army there could threaten Richmond’s breadbasket. Low hills surround the town, which made it hard to defend and easy for an approaching army to hide its movements.

The result was constant fighting. Three major battles bore the town’s name: First Winchester on May 25, 1862, when Stonewall Jackson routed General Nathaniel Banks; Second Winchester in June 1863, when General Richard Ewell’s corps crushed General Robert Milroy’s garrison on the road to Gettysburg; and Third Winchester on September 19, 1864, when General Philip Sheridan defeated General Jubal Early. Kernstown, Cedar Creek and other fights took place nearby.

Local tradition holds that Winchester changed hands about 72 times, including 13 times in a single day. That count includes every cavalry raid and patrol that briefly took the streets. Historians at Encyclopedia Virginia note that full occupations by one army or the other numbered closer to eleven to thirteen. Either way, no town in the South saw more of the war at its doorstep.

Seward’s Visit in March 1862

Jackson had used Winchester as his headquarters in the winter of 1861-62, and he left reluctantly on the night of March 11, 1862, as Banks’ much larger army approached. Federal troops marched in the next day. After the Battle of Kernstown on March 23, Seward traveled to the town with members of his family and other Washington visitors to thank the Union commanders. It was then that he made his famous remark. Federal officers who served in Winchester repeated the same idea for the rest of the war, and Milroy, who governed the town harshly in 1863, was even more bitter in his comments about the “Secession women.”

How the Women Resisted

With fathers, husbands, brothers and sons away in Confederate gray, the women of Winchester carried on a resistance of their own. They could not fight with muskets, so they fought with manners, clothing and sheer stubbornness.

  • The cold shoulder. Many simply refused to acknowledge Federal soldiers. Diarist Mary Greenhow Lee even complained that some Winchester men were too polite to the occupiers.
  • “Jeff Davis” bonnets. Women wore deep bonnets, nicknamed for the Confederate president, so they would not have to meet the eyes of Union troops. When a provost marshal tried to ban sunbonnets on the street, Lee noted, they became even more popular.
  • Refusing the flag. Women stepped into muddy streets rather than walk beneath the Stars and Stripes. Kate Sperry described ladies taking side streets after Federals hung a large flag across the road, and soldiers later draped one over a hospital entrance so visitors to Confederate wounded would have to pass under it.
  • Caring for the South’s soldiers. Throughout the war they nursed Confederate wounded, hid supplies and fed Southern troops whenever the gray army returned.

Some went further. After First Winchester, several Federal regiments reported that civilians fired on them as they retreated through town. A soldier of the 7th Ohio Infantry wrote that “Charleston, South Carolina could not furnish a female and juvenile population imbued with more bitter sentiments towards the North and her soldiers than this city.”

The “Devil Diarists”

Several of these women kept diaries, and today they are known as the “Devil Diarists” after Seward’s remark. Mary Greenhow Lee began recording the occupation in March 1862 and kept writing until Sheridan expelled her from Winchester in February 1865. Cornelia Peake McDonald described the dead laid out on the courthouse porch after Kernstown. Kate Sperry, Laura Lee and others added their own accounts. Not every voice was Confederate. Unionist Julia Chase welcomed the Federal army, and the town’s enslaved residents saw the war as a path to freedom. Together these writings make Winchester one of the best-documented towns of the war.

General Thomas Stonewall Jackson, who made Winchester his headquarters in 1861-62

Stonewall Cemetery: The Women Bury Their Dead

When the war ended, the women of Winchester turned their devotion to the fallen. Confederate dead lay in shallow graves on farms and battlefields across the lower Valley. The local Ladies’ Memorial Association, one of the first of its kind in the South, organized to gather them. Volunteers collected the remains of Southern soldiers from a radius of about fifteen miles around the town and reburied them in a new Confederate section of Mount Hebron Cemetery, named the Stonewall Cemetery in honor of Jackson.

Winchester held one of the first Confederate Memorial Day observances in June 1866. On October 25, 1866, a crowd estimated at five thousand gathered to dedicate the cemetery, which at that time held about 2,494 soldiers. Today the cemetery’s caretakers count roughly 2,575 Confederates, many of them unknown, arranged by state. Among them rests General Turner Ashby, Jackson’s famous cavalry leader. A monument to the unknown dead followed in 1879. The Winchester National Cemetery for Union soldiers lies nearby.

That work of remembrance may be the most lasting legacy of the women Seward called devils. They kept faith with the soldiers of the South in war and in peace.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who said “the women are the devils” about Winchester?

U.S. Secretary of State William H. Seward made the remark after visiting Winchester, Virginia, in March 1862, saying the men were all in the army.

How many times did Winchester, Virginia change hands in the Civil War?

Tradition says about 72 times, counting brief raids. Historians estimate full occupations by either army at roughly eleven to thirteen.

What were Jeff Davis bonnets?

They were deep bonnets Confederate women in Winchester wore so they would not have to look at or be seen by Union soldiers.

Who were the Devil Diarists of Winchester?

They were Winchester women, including Mary Greenhow Lee, Cornelia Peake McDonald and Kate Sperry, whose wartime diaries recorded life under occupation.

How many Confederate soldiers are buried in Stonewall Cemetery?

About 2,575 Confederate soldiers rest in Stonewall Cemetery at Mount Hebron in Winchester, many of them unknown. It was dedicated on October 25, 1866.

What battles were fought at Winchester?

The First, Second and Third Battles of Winchester were fought in 1862, 1863 and 1864, with Kernstown and Cedar Creek nearby.

Remember the Valley’s Defenders

Learn how Jackson earned his name in “There Stands Jackson, Like a Stone Wall” and read about Northern aid to the Shenandoah Valley in 1865. Honor the Old Dominion with a State of Virginia Flag, fly the “Stainless Banner” with our 2nd National Confederate Flag in double nylon embroidered, or remember a Valley regiment with the 17th Virginia Infantry Cotton Flag.

Thanks for reading. Please share our posts with your friends and family so they too can learn more about Southern Heritage and History.

Brought to you by: Ultimate Flags